First Time Penalty Abatement and IRS Penalty Relief
Penalties are often the part of a tax bill that hurts most, and the part people most often pay without asking whether they had to. First time penalty abatement, reasonable cause relief and the IRS’s new automatic exemption can remove penalties that would otherwise stay on your account for good. The IRS also removes the interest charged on those penalties when it removes the penalties (IRS).

A+ Tax Experts requests penalty relief from the IRS, the Pennsylvania Department of Revenue and the City of Philadelphia. The firm is led by Nick Ananin, JD, EA, a tax attorney and IRS Enrolled Agent.
“Nick helped me to get a relief of $5000 unnecessary penalties.” (Viyaleta Humennaya)
Which Penalties Can Be Removed?
The relief programs below cover the three penalties that most often appear on IRS notices (IRS):
- Failure to file: 5% of the unpaid tax per month, up to 25%, on late returns, plus the penalties for late partnership and S corporation returns
- Failure to pay: 0.5% per month, up to 25%, on tax not paid by the due date or by the date in an IRS bill
- Failure to deposit: for business payroll and other tax deposits that were late, short or made the wrong way
Other penalties, such as the accuracy-related penalty after an audit, follow different rules. Reasonable cause can still apply to many of them, but not to the estimated tax penalty (IRS).
First Time Penalty Abatement: Who Qualifies
First Time Abate (FTA) is IRS administrative relief for taxpayers with a good record. You qualify if (IRS):
- You filed the same type of return on time for the prior three years (or 12 consecutive quarters for quarterly filers), and
- No penalties were assessed in that period, other than the estimated tax penalty, or any that were assessed were later removed for reasonable cause or IRS error.
Businesses must also meet two more conditions: the IRS did not waive a failure-to-deposit penalty for them four or more times during those three years, and the deposit penalty was not charged for avoiding the Electronic Federal Tax Payment System.
FTA is not available for returns filed only once or rarely because of a specific event, for the daily delinquency penalty, or for information reporting that depends on another filing.
How to request it. You call the IRS at the number on the notice or send a written request or Form 843. You do not need to name FTA or attach documents; the IRS checks your account. And if you ask for reasonable cause relief by phone and qualify for FTA, the IRS applies FTA instead (IRS).
Because FTA is not automatic for past years, a person who qualifies can still end up paying the penalty, simply because nobody asked.
New in 2026: Automatic Exemption From Penalty
The IRS is moving from FTA to a new system called the Automatic Exemption from Penalty (AEP), starting in summer 2026 (IRS). Here is how the two compare:
| First Time Abate | Automatic Exemption from Penalty | |
|---|---|---|
| Years covered | Prior years and periods, plus eligible returns not considered for AEP | 2025 tax year returns and 2026 quarterly returns, and later |
| How it works | The penalty is assessed, then removed on request | The penalty is never assessed |
| What you do | Contact the IRS and ask | Nothing; the IRS sends a letter explaining the relief |
| Late-payment penalty | May keep accruing until the tax is paid | Not assessed on the unpaid tax |
AEP applies to Forms 1040, 1065, 1120, 940, 941, 943, 944, 945 and CT-1. You are still responsible for the tax, the interest and any penalties AEP does not cover. According to the IRS’s interim guidance, a return must be filed within three years of its original due date to be considered for AEP, and FTA will no longer be available for eligible returns originally due on or after January 1, 2027 (IRS interim guidance, IRM 20.1.1.3.3.2.5).
What this means for you: if you were late on a 2025 return and have a clean history, check your notice. If it shows a penalty you believe AEP should have prevented, the IRS asks you to contact it, and we can do that for you. For tax year 2024 and earlier, and for 2025 returns that did not get AEP consideration, FTA is still the route, and you still have to ask.
Reasonable Cause Relief
If you do not qualify for administrative relief, or the penalty is not covered, reasonable cause is the next option. The IRS grants it when you show you used ordinary business care and prudence and still could not file or pay on time (IRS). Examples the IRS gives include:
- Fire, natural disaster or civil disturbance
- Inability to get records
- Death, serious illness or unavoidable absence of the taxpayer or an immediate family member
- System issues that delayed an electronic filing or payment
What usually does not qualify on its own: relying on a tax preparer, not knowing the rules, simple mistakes, and lack of money. The IRS does consider extra facts that show you tried to comply.
A reasonable cause request lives or dies on the explanation. The IRS wants to know what happened and when, how it stopped you from filing or paying, and what you did to comply once you could. It expects proof: hospital records or a doctor’s letter with start and end dates, disaster documentation, letters and receipts (IRS). We write the request as a clear timeline matched to the documents, the way an examiner reads it.
Pennsylvania and Philadelphia Penalties
The same idea works locally, through different offices.
- Pennsylvania. To challenge a Pennsylvania assessment, including penalties, you file a petition with the Department of Revenue’s Board of Appeals, online or by mail. The deadline is printed on the Notice of Assessment, and the Board does not accept petitions by email or fax (Pennsylvania Department of Revenue).
- City of Philadelphia. You have the right to appeal interest and penalty charges. If accrued interest is under $15,000 and penalties are under $35,000, you can file a Petition for Waiver of Interest and Penalty with the Philadelphia Department of Revenue. Larger amounts go to the Tax Review Board (City of Philadelphia). A petition to the Tax Review Board that contests the amount due is generally due within 60 days of the mailing date of the first notice (Tax Review Board regulations).
City penalties can build up on Business Income & Receipts Tax, Net Profits Tax, Wage Tax and other accounts, and each route has its own deadline. One client wrote about her case with the city:
“Nick Ananin did a fantastic job, and was able to resolve my issue with the city of Philadelphia.” (Katherine)
Results depend on the facts of each case, and past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
How We Handle a Penalty Abatement Request
- Identify every penalty. With your power of attorney, we pull the account transcripts and list each penalty by type, year and amount.
- Check administrative relief first. We test FTA and AEP before reasonable cause, because they need no explanation of hardship.
- Build the reasonable cause case. Where it fits, we prepare a written request backed by documents.
- Choose the channel. Some penalties can be removed in a single call; others need Form 843 or a written appeal.
- Appeal if needed. If the IRS denies the request, we take it to the IRS Independent Office of Appeals.
- Confirm the result. We check the transcript to make sure the penalty and the interest on it came off.
One timing note: FTA applies to a single tax period. When penalties are being considered for several periods, the IRS applies FTA to the earliest one that qualifies and judges the others on reasonable cause (IRS procedural update SBSE-20-0414). If you have penalties in several years, plan the request before you call.
What to Bring
- The notices that show the penalties
- The returns for the years involved
- Proof of what caused the delay, if any: medical records, disaster records, letters
- For businesses: payroll reports and deposit confirmations
Request Penalty Relief
Call (215) 914-6929 or request a consultation. We will tell you which penalties can realistically come off and the best way to ask. Penalty abatement requests are quoted individually, and the written quote is free; see our price list. If penalties are part of a larger balance, see IRS tax debt help and IRS representation and tax resolution.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does first time penalty abatement remove interest?
It removes the interest charged on the abated penalty. Interest on the underlying tax generally stays, because it is not a penalty.
Can I use first time abatement more than once?
Yes, but not often. A penalty removed under FTA still counts against your history, so you need three new clean years before FTA is available again (IRS Office of Chief Counsel memorandum PMTA-2018-2). Only penalties removed for reasonable cause or IRS error do not count.
Do I need to pay the tax first?
Not necessarily, but it helps to arrange payment at the same time, for example with a payment plan. Under FTA, the late-payment penalty may keep growing until the balance is paid in full, so relief granted early may not cover what accrues later.
Can a tax professional’s mistake count as reasonable cause?
Generally not by itself, because the IRS holds you responsible for what your preparer files. The IRS may still consider relief when you relied on a competent advisor and gave them all the information they needed, especially for accuracy-related penalties.